Selling Sunset's Jason Oppenheim’s Dating History: Chrishell, More (2025)

California love. Selling Sunset star Jason Oppenheim has dated several of his costars — including Nicole Young and Chrishell Stause.While Young joined the cast of the Netflix reality series for season 6, which premiered in May 2023, her relationship with Oppenheim started and ended long before her reality TV debut.“[Nicole] dated Jason [10 years ago] — she was the first,” Amanza Smith exclusively revealed to Us Weekly in August 2022. “I’ve known her for 10 years and she’s amazing. She’s not new to me. I’m just very glad that she’s finally on the show with us and we get to spend more time with her in the office because I adore Nicole.”Despite being a late addition to Selling Sunset, Young is an original member of The Oppenheim Group. “I’m the OG … original girlfriend,” she quipped during a season 6 episode of the series. The realtor — who has been married to Brandon Young since 2017 — referred to Oppenheim as the “best broker in the biz” in a March 2019 Instagram post.Young isn’t the only ex with whom Oppenheim has maintained an amicable personal and professional relationship. In season 1 of Selling Sunset, which premiered in March 2019, the attorney hosted an engagement party for his ex Mary Fitzgerald and her now-husband, Romain Bonnet.[jwplayer C21yrSXq-zhNYySv2]The exes were an item in 2014 for “six months to a year,” the Oppenheim Group founder recalled during a season 1 episode of the reality series. He added that he and Fitzgerald — who has worked for his real estate agency since 2014 — “were good friends before [they dated] and we’re much closer now.”The real estate mogul and Stause, meanwhile, were friends and coworkers before they went public with their romance in July 2021. When the Kentucky native joined the Oppenheim Group in 2018, she had recently married Justin Hartley. (The former spouses called it quits in 2019 and finalized their split in February 2021.)Oppenheim exclusively told Us in November 2021 that his friendship with Stause provided a great basis for their romantic relationship.“We had been so open about what we were looking for with each other because we had become close friends," he shared at the time. "She knew my dating life, and we would almost joke about each other’s dating lives and what we were looking for and things like that."One month after Oppenheim dished to Us about his romance with the Days of Our Lives alum, the duo split just before Christmas 2021. However, they didn’t let the breakup sour their dynamic as pals.“Chrishell and I started off close friends before we were together, and we're back, we're in a great place," Oppenheim told E! News in July 2022. "I think we're both really happy right now, and we get along really well."Stause has since moved on with G Flip and the pair tied the knot in May 2023.Keep scrolling for a look at Oppenheim’s dating history:

The realtors dated in the early 2010s, years before Selling Sunset premiered in 2019.

Fitzgerald and Oppenheim dated for about a year in 2014. “We had a lingering kind of period,” Fitzgerald said during a season 1 episode of Selling Sunset, noting that the twosome took a while to split for good. “We lived together.”

Stause and Oppenheim went public with their relationship in July 2021, but by December, their whirlwind romance had ended. Later that month, the Eve of Abduction actress confirmed they called it quits due to Oppenheim not wanting children.

“Jason was and is my best friend, and other than our ideas for family ultimately not being aligned, the amount of respect and love we have for each other will not change going forward,” she wrote via Instagram at the time.

The businessman and the model were first linked in July 2022 when they were spotted kissing in Mykonos, Greece. In May 2023, the pair confirmed they had split after less than one year of dating.

"While we still love and care about each other very much, the distance between us has proven to be too great a challenge to overcome,” they wrote in a joint statement shared via their respective Instagram pages. “We remain close friends and continue to talk often and support each other and we want the very best for one another. We thank everyone for their support throughout our relationship.”

In April 2025, Oppenheim made his new relationship with Jessica Vargas red carpet official.

The Selling Sunset star walked the red carpet with the real estate agent at the Los Angeles premiere of The Accountant 2.

According to her real estate profile, Vargas is a realtor at The Oppenheim Group and “represents clients from the Valley, West Hollywood, to Malibu, Beverly Hills and beyond.”

While it’s unclear if Vargas will be part of Selling Sunset season 9, her profile states she enjoys spending time with family, friends and her two dogs when not working.

In this article